Wednesday, December 21, 2016

Ugly Truth: Line6 Spider V Amps

Alright so here's the thing, there is a palpable hate toward this entire range of amplifiers. Nearly every guitar player has played through one of these amps, or at least have heard one played. The Spider line has taken more hits than Louisville-Slugger, and has served as the whipping post for anyone putting digital modeling amps on blast. Line6 has doubled down on the Spider name. They have released the fifth generation of the Spider despite any of the negative feedback. Perhaps they've listened to the criticism and produced a better product. It is clear that the stigma still lingers over the Spider name. Do these amp deserve this kind of hate? Well, here is truth:




They Are Well Equipped

The features on the Line6 Spider V amps are actually one of the most interesting things about them. Sure, there are a lot of different sounds on board, as there are with all the amps in this range. The addition of control via mobile device is robust and intuitive. It feels like there was a lot of time spent on interface of the app. Probably the biggest feature that gets overlooked on these amps is its ability to function as an acoustic amp. Equipped with a tweeter, this combo can do more than model electric amps and effects. This alone makes it a little more than meets the eye. In addition, there is actually an integrated wireless receiver with their Relay Go System (In the bigger units). This makes them wireless ready right out of the box.  Also, these amp are compatible with the  FBV control pedal. Making them very easy customize and switch between settings. The third gen  FBV control pedal actually barrows from the Helix motif, color coding the each footswitch according to the effect that it t triggers. Again this is only available on the larger units. And they (the Relay Go and FBV) aren't "features" as much as they are options, as in optional, as in they don't come with it, but you can buy them... making this sizable purchase into a more sizable purchase... causing the whole thing to become rather...


...Expensive

Yeah, even compared to the other offerings in this range, the Line6 Spider V is pricey. Coming in at the higher end of the watt/dollar range, these amp command a hefty sum for what seems like a checkered legacy. That's before you start looking at the optional foot control pedal. (that will set you back another $250) and wireless adapters. It's hard see why the Sider V has to be head and shoulders above in price, when they are competing directly with unit that costs (in some cases) hundreds less. Marshal, Black Star, Boss and Vox all have recently updated their line of make-all-the-sounds boxes and appear to be an attractive value in comparison. And while we're talking about being attractive...




They're Ugly


Yeah, they look like cosmetics were not even considered. I'm not sure if they were going for a modern look, but they failed. I'm not the biggest fan of new gear trying to cop a vintage vibe, but it appears that the Spider V is just phoning it in. It is minimalism and sleek-ish, but it's not winning any beauty contest. Objectively, function trumps form in most cases, but when deciding what amp will set the stage (literally) for your overall vibe aesthetics have to be considered.


Conclusion


While I will concede that this amp often get blamed for a multitude of undeserved sins, some of the blame is well earned. Many guitarist start their musical journey with one of the Spider amps. The popularity of these amp is undeniable. When starting out, these amps promise an feature-laden do-it-all machine. However, after acquiring experience many user discover areas where these amps suffer. The truth is, that these amps are fantastic for a beginner looking to experience a multitude of sounds without have to invest thousands into a collection of gear that would ultimately go underutilized. Just like every other product out there, these amps have a undying following as well as detractors. While features and connectivity are growing and becoming more user friendly, these amps will probably never ascend to their aspired heights. What we need to do is to realize that there is no magic bullet, and if there were, it would extremely expensive. These amp have a place, but they are probably not the only amp you'll ever need. More specifically, the Spider V is not even my top choice of modeling amplifier. If you are looking for a amp with a solid reputation, check out the Vox Valvetronix line. If you want something more innovative and inexpensive, look at the BOSS Katana. The Spider line IMHO is a chronic underperformer.



Support the blog by shopping on Amazon by using my link!


There should be an ad below:





3 comments:

  1. Hmm. Looks like you checked out the Point of sale spiel and photos and didn't actually try one. A pretty good well rounded review minus the footpedal can be found here: https://youtu.be/CSiCQV3fDRc

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. At the time this post was written, I had no been able to try one of these amplifiers. There is a lot of information about these amp and other products when they come to market. I like to answer the questions "Is this worth a closer look?" and "What mistakes did the manufacture make?" in these types of post. However, be on the lookout for a Hands On Review where I talk more in depth about the products performance.

      Thanks for the comment!

      Delete
    2. I have been using one with wireless for about a month now and have mixed feelings. I read your recent reviews today and decided to try the CODE 50 and Spider V side by side.

      It's funny how on their own you can forgive minor issues because they all have positives and negatives. But I noticed today that the CODE has better dynamics, both picking and aural. I like all the effects and having everything in one box but I'm seriously considering getting a seperate G10 I can use with other gear because in the end that and the full range audio through USB were the outstanding things I liked most about the Spider V.

      Delete